Alex is Sprintlaw’s co-founder and principal lawyer. Alex previously worked at a top-tier firm as a lawyer specialising in technology and media contracts, and founded a digital agency which he sold in 2015.
Working out how to pay a company director isn’t just a tax question - it’s a legal, payroll and governance decision that affects your cash flow, compliance and investor confidence.
If you’re running a small company, you’ll want a simple, compliant approach that keeps HMRC happy, aligns with your growth plans and is fair to everyone around the table.
This guide breaks down your options for a director of a company salary, how approvals work under the Companies Act 2006, and the payroll steps you can’t skip. We’ll also flag common pitfalls and share practical tips you can put to work today.
What Counts As A Director’s Salary Under UK Law?
“Director’s salary” is often used as shorthand for any money a director receives from the company. In legal terms, it helps to separate these categories:
- Salary and wages: Pay for work done, usually under a service agreement. Subject to PAYE income tax and employee/employer National Insurance (NI).
- Bonuses and benefits: Performance awards, allowances, cars, private medical, etc. Taxable and often reportable on P11D.
- Dividends: Payments to shareholders from post-tax profits. Not salary - different tax treatment and only payable if there are distributable profits.
- Expenses: Reimbursements for genuine business costs. Non-taxable if they meet HMRC rules and are properly evidenced.
Directors are “office-holders” under UK law. An office-holder can also be an employee. Whether employment law (like minimum wage or paid holiday) applies depends on whether the director also has a contract of employment or a worker or employee relationship with the company.
In practice, many small companies appoint directors and put in place a clear Directors Service Agreement to set responsibilities, pay, notice and restraint clauses. This gives certainty and helps with compliance and investor due diligence later.
How Should You Pay A Director: Salary, Dividends Or A Mix?
There’s no one-size-fits-all. Most small companies choose a mix of modest salary and dividends, but the right balance depends on your profit forecast, cash needs and risk profile.
Option 1: Salary-Only
Paying a market salary keeps things simple, ensures regular pension contributions (if applicable) and avoids dividend paperwork.
Pros:
- Predictable cash outflows and straightforward PAYE.
- May help benchmark pay for other staff and avoid perceived unfairness.
Cons:
- Higher NI cost compared to dividends.
- Less flexibility if profits fluctuate.
Option 2: Dividends-Only
Some companies try to avoid salary altogether. Be careful - dividends are for shareholders only, must be paid out of distributable profits, and should never be used to replace payment for ongoing work if there’s a genuine employment relationship.
Risks:
- Unlawful dividends if there are insufficient profits.
- Potential employment law and tax risks if HMRC considers the director is effectively an employee being paid as dividends.
Option 3: Mixed Approach
A common approach for small companies is a basic salary through PAYE plus dividends when profits allow. This can be tax-efficient and flexible. For a deeper dive into tax planning and thresholds, see our guide to a director salary and dividends.
Don’t Forget Bonuses And Equity
If you use performance bonuses, be clear about metrics, caps and discretion in the director’s service agreement or a bonus policy. You might also consider share options to align incentives over the long-term, including EMI options for eligible companies.
Where ownership is shared, use a Shareholders Agreement to agree dividend policy, remuneration principles and approvals, so pay decisions don’t derail relationships.
Payroll, Tax And Pensions: What Employers Must Do
Once you decide on the approach, you need to run director pay correctly through your systems.
Register For PAYE And Run Payroll
- Register as an employer with HMRC and run payroll under PAYE.
- Apply director-specific rules: Directors have an annual earnings period for NI - you can apply the annual or alternative method. Your payroll software or accountant can help select the right one.
- Report in real time: Submit Full Payment Submissions (FPS) on or before payday and pay tax/NI to HMRC by the deadlines.
National Minimum Wage (NMW)
NMW doesn’t apply to directors purely as office-holders. However, if the director also has an employment contract, NMW rules can apply to the salaried element. Make sure your documentation matches the reality of how the director works.
Pensions And Auto-Enrolment
- If your company has more than one person who meets the worker criteria, auto-enrolment duties will likely apply.
- A sole director company with no other staff usually has no auto-enrolment duty, but this can change the moment you hire.
Benefits In Kind And Expenses
- Taxable benefits (e.g. company car, private medical) are reportable on P11D unless payrolled.
- Pay only legitimate business expenses, keep receipts, and follow HMRC rules for travel, subsistence and home-working.
Bonuses And Variable Pay
Performance bonuses must go through payroll and may trigger additional NI and tax. Put clear terms around eligibility and discretion, and remember that variable pay can affect holiday pay calculations if the director is also an employee. For policy design and pitfalls, see our guidance on bonus pay.
Setting And Approving Director Pay: Governance And Disclosure
Director remuneration isn’t just a private matter - there are governance and disclosure rules to follow under the Companies Act 2006 and accounting standards.
Who Decides Director Pay?
- Board decisions: In many small companies, the board determines director pay, often guided by the company’s constitution or a shareholders’ agreement.
- Shareholder approval: Long-term service contracts with directors (guaranteed term over two years) require shareholder approval (Companies Act 2006, s.188).
- Conflicts of interest: A director should not take part in decisions where they have a personal interest unless your constitution permits and the conflict is properly declared and managed.
Recording The Decision
- Pass a board resolution (and shareholder resolution where needed) and keep accurate minutes.
- Update the Directors Service Agreement or issue a variation letter if pay terms change.
- Make sure payroll reflects the new pay from the effective date.
Disclosure In Accounts
Companies must disclose directors’ remuneration in their annual accounts. The level of detail varies with company size, but expect to show aggregate remuneration for all directors and, for certain companies, information about the highest paid director. For a refresher on the rules and practicalities, see our guide to directors’ remuneration.
Dividends And Profit Law
Dividends must come from distributable profits. Before declaring a dividend, prepare management accounts to confirm profits, pass a board resolution, and issue dividend vouchers. Paying “dividends” to non-shareholders (or without profits) can create unlawful distributions with personal repayment risks. Where different shareholders receive different amounts, be mindful of unequal dividends rules and potential tax consequences.
Employment Law Considerations For Director Pay
Many small-company directors wear two hats: office-holder and employee. That mix has legal consequences for pay, process and disputes.
Service Agreement Vs Employment Contract
A comprehensive Directors Service Agreement sets expectations around duties, confidentiality, IP ownership, pay, bonuses, benefits, post-termination restraints and notice. If a director also holds a managerial role, it’s common to include employment-style terms. For non-board executives, use an Employment Contract tailored to senior roles.
Consistency And Fairness
Pay should be objectively justifiable and consistent with your remuneration framework. If you’re moving from founder-only to a wider team, align director and employee pay practices to avoid grievances or equal pay issues.
Deductions And Overpayments
Don’t make ad hoc deductions from salary without a contractual right or the director’s written consent. If an overpayment occurs, act quickly and lawfully to recover it. Your finance team should understand the rules on wage deductions and how to document repayment - these same principles apply to directors and employees.
Incentives, Clawback And Leaver Provisions
Incentive schemes should cover vesting, malus/clawback and what happens on resignation or dismissal. Align these with your shareholders’ agreement to avoid disputes when a founder-director exits. Consider how option grants interact with any Shareholders Agreement dragging, tagging or good/bad leaver mechanics.
Practical Examples And Common Mistakes To Avoid
Example 1: The “Dividends Instead Of Salary” Trap
A founder works full-time but takes only dividends to “save tax”. When profits dip, the director still withdraws cash as “interim dividends” without available profits. Result: unlawful distributions, potential personal liability to repay, and a messy trail when raising investment. Fix: run a reasonable salary through PAYE and declare dividends only from distributable profits evidenced by accounts.
Example 2: No Paper Trail For Pay Decisions
A two-director company agrees informally that one director gets a higher salary after taking on sales. There are no board minutes, no update to the service agreement and payroll keeps paying the old rate. Months later, the relationship breaks down and there’s a dispute over back pay. Fix: minute the decision, update the contract, and sync payroll immediately.
Example 3: Bonuses With Vague Criteria
Bonuses are announced verbally (“we’ll sort it at year end”). Expectations diverge, and one director claims a guaranteed bonus. Fix: put clear criteria and discretion wording in the agreement and ensure any variable pay is processed through payroll, in line with your bonus pay policy.
Example 4: Loans Masquerading As Pay
A director takes frequent drawings from the company to “smooth cash flow” without setting salary. The director’s loan account becomes overdrawn, triggering s.455 CTA charges and benefit-in-kind issues. Fix: decide on salary/dividends formally, or if a loan is needed, document it properly and understand the rules around director loans.
Checklist: Set Up Your Director Pay The Right Way
- Agree the pay mix: salary, dividends, bonus, benefits, options.
- Document via a Directors Service Agreement and board/shareholder resolutions.
- Register for PAYE, configure director NI rules, and run RTI payroll.
- Assess auto-enrolment duties and benefits reporting (P11D or payrolling).
- Confirm distributable profits before declaring dividends and keep vouchers.
- Ensure your Shareholders Agreement covers remuneration principles and approvals.
Key Takeaways
- A director of a company salary sits within a broader remuneration package - separate salary, bonuses, benefits, expenses and dividends so each is handled correctly.
- Most small companies use a mixed approach: modest salary via PAYE plus dividends when there are distributable profits. Review your plan annually and keep a paper trail.
- Put clear terms in a Directors Service Agreement, and align incentives (bonus, options) with governance documents like your Shareholders Agreement.
- Follow payroll rules: register for PAYE, apply director NI rules, report in real time, assess auto-enrolment, and handle benefits/expenses correctly.
- Get the approvals right: manage conflicts, minute decisions, and obtain shareholder approval for long-term director contracts where required by the Companies Act 2006.
- Avoid common mistakes like unlawful dividends, undocumented pay changes, and using loans or drawings as informal “pay”. If in doubt, take tailored advice early.
- For tax-efficiency strategies and thresholds, see our deeper guide to a director salary, and consider incentives such as EMI options as you grow.
If you’d like help setting up director pay, drafting a Directors Service Agreement or aligning your board approvals, you can reach us at 08081347754 or team@sprintlaw.co.uk for a free, no-obligations chat.


